Love Is Blind Reunion Rumors Claim John Had an Emotional Affair—and Rob Was Along for the Night Out

Photo courtesy of Netflix

The Lowdown

The divorce filing is real. The reason behind it? That part is still pure scuttlebutt. Reality TV recapper Kate Riccio is passing along alleged Reddit leaks about the Love Is Blind Season 11 reunion, and they say John Shannon had an “emotional affair.” Her own caption says it best: “Crazy!!! (if true).”

Key Takeaways

Confirmed: Sarah Williams filed for divorce from John Shannon in Massachusetts on June 4, 2026, according to court documents reported by USA Today and People.
Rumor: In an Instagram reel posted Nov. 5, Kate Riccio (@ricciorecaps) shares alleged Reddit leaks claiming the reunion covers an “emotional affair.” She calls it all alleged.
Per those leaks, Sarah allegedly found texts between John and a sex worker he met on a night out with castmate Rob. The leaks call it emotional, not physical.
Neither John nor Sarah has publicly addressed the claims, and Netflix hasn’t commented.
The reunion streams Sunday, Nov. 8, at 9 p.m. ET on Netflix (Netflix Tudum).

View this reel from Kate Riccio (@ricciorecaps) on Instagram

Source: Kate Riccio on Instagram (@ricciorecaps)

The Full Story

Here’s what’s on the record. According to Massachusetts court documents first reported by TMZ and reviewed by USA Today, Sarah filed to end the marriage on June 4, citing an irretrievable breakdown. The filing lists a March 27, 2025, wedding and an April 15, 2026, separation, so the split was already in court months before Netflix aired the finale wedding on Nov. 4. We broke down the filing here.

Here’s the gossip. In her reel, Riccio first recaps the divorce news. Then she moves on to what she says Reddit users are claiming about the reunion, which was taped before it streams. She’s upfront about it: “now what I am about to tell you is alleged.” She keeps saying it’s all alleged.

According to the leaks Riccio describes, Sarah allegedly caught John texting a sex worker he’d met on a night out with castmate Rob. The leaks describe it as an emotional affair, not a physical one. Riccio also passes along claimed friction over household roles, plus a claim about how a family member reacted. None of it comes with receipts: the reel shows no Reddit posts or documents, and we couldn’t confirm the claims.

Riccio isn’t the only one hearing it. Before the filing went public, podcaster Rikkii Wise (@storytimewithrikkii) made a similar claim on an Oct. 30 episode, as reported by The Tab and Cosmopolitan. “So they’re calling it an emotional affair,” Wise said, per The Tab. Two people repeating a rumor still doesn’t confirm it. The court filing doesn’t give a reason beyond an irretrievable breakdown.

The reunion teaser may have dropped a hint. In it, host Nick Lachey asks someone off camera, “did you cheat on your wife?” (E! News). The teaser doesn’t show who he’s asking. Neither John nor Sarah has commented publicly on the split or the claims. Sunday’s reunion should tell us how much of this Reddit chatter holds up.

The Pit Take

In our opinion, this is how reality TV works now: the court docs show up first, the Reddit leaks come next, and the reunion arrives last. Until John or Sarah talks, treat the affair story as fan chatter, not fact. What do you think, is the reunion going to confirm it or blow it up? More in Reality TV.